While Pitchfork is one of the best sites to visit to discover great new indie music, it’s also one of those sites that drives me nuts when I read reviews, mostly due to their extremely picky and highly opinionated staff. It’s both a blessing and a curse though as you definitely get an honest look at an album that’s less than desirable, but it’s not fun when they’re tearing apart an album you enjoy piece by piece. But, c’est la vie.
So when I saw that their staff has been counting down their top 200 albums of the 2000s I was both intrigued and nervous. I’ve been waiting to see which album won the top honor and was pleasantly surprised when it turned out to be one of my favorites of all time. Score one for alignment!

When I first heard Kid A I was in love. It was a serious departure from their previous album and highly experimental, but still quintessential Radiohead. The first few notes of “Everything in it’s Right Place” pluck you out from where you are and transport you to an otherworldly audio landscape that feels seemingly inescapable until you work your way through all 10 tracks. And let me say, while that’s not a huge number of tracks, they are each so richly composed that you feel like you’ve been on just as long of a journey as you would had you gone through the 24 on Sufjan Steven’s “Come On Feel the Illinoise” (which is interestingly enough #16 on Pitchfork’s list).
I love songs like “The National Anthem” with it’s buzzing bassline and the swirling flow of “How to Disappear Completely”, but it’s track 8 “Idioteque” that is the stand out one for me. Radiohead took a sample from 1970s electronic composer Paul Lansky’s “Mild und Leise” and laced that through their chirping, punchy, electronic beats of their own. Idioteque is easily a crowd favorite at Radiohead’s live shows and is surprisingly a track that translates well into the live arena. Following Idioteque is my favorite rendition of “Morning Bell” (the alternate on “Amnesiac” is noteworthy, but just not as good), with one of the most catchy drum-lines I know by Mr. Phil Selway.
Of course had Pitchfork’s list encompassed the 1990’s I’d dare say that OK Computer would have given Kid A a serious run for it’s money. I’m continually on the fence between those two albums as to which one is Radiohead’s best. While Kid A is brilliant, OK Computer is a powerhouse of an album and the one that skyrocketed Radiohead out of their initial dissatisfactory mainstream successes and into the fan and critic darlings they are today. And speaking of Selway’s drum-lines, the one from “Airbag” is gorgeous isn’t it?!